London: "Horrendous" is not a word anyone wants to hear in their appraisal. It was, however, the one chosen by Conor OShea, the man responsible for overseeing England's international success, to describe the men's team's 2026 Six Nations campaign. Many fans find it entirely apt, as England won only one match, marking their worst return since the tournament's expansion a quarter of a century ago. The team lacked cohesion, discipline, and tactical variety, prompting profound questions about the future of head coach Steve Borthwick.
According to BBC, despite the poor performance, Conor OShea revealed to Rugby Union Weekly that Steve Borthwick's contract has been extended. Borthwick's terms now stretch beyond the 2027 Rugby World Cup in Australia to the end of the Six Nations the following year. The decision to extend Borthwick's contract, despite the criticism of England's performances, is intriguing to many. However, OShea explains that providing job security to coaches is crucial to maintaining focus and allowing time to evaluate the coaching staff's performance properly during and after the World Cup.
While New Zealand's swift improvement under new coach Dave Rennie might raise eyebrows, England is determined to support Borthwick through the upcoming tournament. The additional six months added to Borthwick's deal is not a significant vote of confidence. Rather, it is a strategic move to prevent speculation about his future during the World Cup and to allow the RFU time to make a well-considered decision post-tournament.
The RFU's approach mirrors a similar tactic used with the Red Roses. As they approached their World Cup title in 2025, the RFU had extended coach John Mitchell's contract, preventing any abrupt decisions post-victory. This strategy allowed them to secure Mitchell for another four years following their win.
OShea also reflected on the 2015 Rugby World Cup, where England was knocked out in the pool stages. He believes the RFU acted too hastily in dismissing the coaching group led by Stuart Lancaster, which included future successful coaches. He contrasts this with New Zealand's steadfast faith in their coaching team after a shock 2007 World Cup exit, a decision that ultimately led to consecutive World Cup victories.
If England fails to perform well in the next Rugby World Cup, it is unlikely Borthwick will receive another contract extension. England's favorable draw means they may not face top teams like South Africa, New Zealand, or France until a potential final. The semi-finals are the minimum expectation for England, and anything less could jeopardize Borthwick's position. With a winning percentage below 60% and limited success in implementing a new game plan, Borthwick has little margin for error.
Back in March, RFU chief executive Bill Sweeney explained that succession planning continues to identify the next England head coach, as it does for all senior roles within the organization. Despite Borthwick's public contract extension, preparations for succession are ongoing and will intensify as the World Cup cycle progresses.
